WHY GEOTHERMAL?
Geothermal vs. Air-Source Heat Pumps
Replacing Oil or Propane Heat in the Hudson Valley?
Replacing your oil or propane heating system is an opportunity to improve comfort, add summer cooling and invest in your home’s long-term performance. Geothermal and air-source heat pumps both offer more efficient heating and cooling, but their differences matter when choosing a system you’ll rely on for years.
Air-source systems exchange heat with outdoor air. Geothermal uses underground piping to draw on stable ground temperatures from the Earth, supporting steady, efficient heating as outdoor temperatures fall.
For Hudson Valley homeowners, that winter performance is a compelling reason to consider geothermal before committing to another system.
At Taproot Geo, geothermal is our specialty. We assess your current heating, property and goals to explain what installation would involve and whether the investment makes sense for your home. From system design through installation and ongoing service, we manage the complete geothermal project.
How Geothermal and Air-Source Heat Pumps Compare
Feature | Geothermal (GSHP) | Air-Source Heat Pump (ASHP) |
|---|---|---|
Overall ROI | Highest in cold climates like the Hudson Valley | Lower upfront cost, higher operating cost |
Efficiency in Winter | Always high | Drops in Hudson Valley Winters |
Defrost Mode | Not needed | Can affect comfort |
Efficiency vs. Fuel Oil or Propane | ∼300–600% more efficient year round | ∼200–400% more efficient, performance can decline in colder weather |
Outdoor Equipment | None | Required |
Expected Lifespan | ∼20–25 years (unit), ∼50+ years (loop) | ∼15–20 years |
Noise Level | Silent outdoors | Outdoor compressor noise |
Make the Switch to Geothermal with Taproot
Replace Oil or Propane
Heating and cooling bills are reduced by 50-70% or more, year-round.
No Fuel Deliveries
No oil or propane contracts or fluctuating gas prices.
Minimal Maintenance
No annual tune-ups, just air filter changes.
Reduced Carbon Footprint
More impactful than solar panels or EVs. One of the most powerful ways to cut emissions.
Year-round Comfort
A system designed around your home's heating and cooling needs.
New York Incentives
State tax credits and utility rebates can reduce upfront costs for eligible projects.